AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |
Back to Blog
Obscure 2 app android9/19/2023 But some critics have pointed out that contact-tracing apps that use Google and Apple's Bluetooth-tracing functionality will inevitably ask for location data anyway. The latter, after all, can be used as evidence of everything from extramarital affairs to political dissent. Tracing Covid-19 infections based on Bluetooth contacts rather than GPS location data avoids a huge privacy concern. Will Contact-Tracing Apps Also Ask for Location Data? "One of the things that we will have to do is make it very clear to people that if they choose to submit a report, they're possibly disclosing to their friends and random strangers the fact of this exposure," Leibrand says. That could also help you determine the identity of the person who later tested positive. Some versions of a Bluetooth-based contact tracing app may choose to alert you with information about the exact time and place when you crossed paths with a person who was later diagnosed as infected, so that you might better assess your risk. The head of one contact-tracing project, Co-Epi founder Scott Leibrand, went so far as to say that the correlation attack is inextricable from an intended function of the contact-tracing protocol. A spokesperson for the Google/Apple team pointed out that if an adversary is willing to use surveillance cameras, they could more easily point them at the entrances to clinics and other testing sites to capture people's faces. But both teams suggested that these sort of correlation attacks would be difficult to do at a large scale. Neither the contact-tracing developers at Google and Apple's joint project nor the TCN consortium had an easy answer to this question. "If you know you might end up on Nextdoor as someone who's infected, you might not be willing to use one of these apps." "While the system itself has anonymous properties, the implementation-because it's broadcasting identifiers-isn't anonymous," Soltani says. If it finds a match with one of its stored codes, the app will notify that person that they may have been exposed, and will then show them information about self-quarantining or getting tested themselves. Everyone else's app then downloads those daily keys and uses them to recreate the unique rotating codes they generated. (Both numbers are "tunable" based on new data about how Covid-19 infections are occurring.) When a user reports a positive Covid-19 diagnosis, their app uploads the cryptographic keys that were used to generate their codes over the last two weeks to a server. At the same time, they'll constantly monitor the phones around them, recording the codes of any other phones they encounter within a certain amount of range and time-say, within six feet for 10 minutes. Contact-tracing apps will constantly broadcast unique, rotating Bluetooth codes that are derived from a cryptographic key that changes once each day. To understand those flaws, first a refresher on how Google and Apple's scheme-and the similar one proposed by the TCN Coalition-will work. Bluetooth-based contact tracing is perhaps the least surveillance-friendly option, but its protections aren't perfect. The likeliest concern for anyone taking part in a contact-tracing system is whether they're signing up for more surveillance. Security and privacy-focused technologists have pointed to a long list of potential flaws in Apple and Google's system, including techniques that could reveal the identities of Covid-19 positive users or help advertisers track them, false positives from trolls, mistaken self-diagnoses, and faulty signals between phones. Apple and Google chose perhaps the most privacy-friendly of the many different schemes that could allow automated smartphone contact tracing.īut that doesn't necessarily mean it's private enough or practical. The system is Bluetooth-only, fully opt-in, collects no location data from users, and no data at all from anyone without a positive Covid-19 diagnosis. If someone later receives a positive Covid-19 diagnosis, they can report it through the app, and any users who have been in recent contact will receive a notification. Now it's time to seek answers.Īpple and Google say that starting next month they'll add new features to their mobile operating systems that make it possible for certain approved apps, run by government health agencies, to use Bluetooth radios to track physical proximity between phones. The notion of a Silicon Valley scheme to monitor yet another metric of our lives raised immediate questions about the system's practicality and its privacy. When Google and Apple announced last week that the two companies are building changes into Android and iOS to enable Bluetooth-based Covid-19 contact tracing, they touched off an immediate firestorm of criticisms.
0 Comments
Read More
Leave a Reply. |